Benjamin Ansin sent in the following:
I was very surprised to see him [Andy] in the final two over Jeremiah (who should have won TE), and pretty much dumb struck to see him win it. Unlike Booker T, who claims Andy has the "it"-factor, I thought he came across as bland and rather douchy on the show. He never stood out. They always show him running out of the corner with a big kick. That seems to be the one thing he can do well. On the stick he wasn't convincing at all. And his whole holier-than-thou "no party, I'm here to work"-attitude was annoying as well. Larger-than-life-personality that ain't.
I do not expect him to achieve anything of note in the WWE. Then again I used to say the same thing about John Morrison and (especially) the Miz. I'm far from an expert. But I just don't see it.
Marc Thomas sent in the following:
If Martin couldn't have won Andy was the next best choice. Also, I would rather have him go down to FCW learn some stuff and then come up, instead of being the "Tough Enough" flavor of the month. I will only be pissed if they pull a [Daniel] Puder and have him on 1 show then get rid of him. He won Tough Enough when he's ready to come up he better have a tiny run.
An anonymous reader sent in the following:
I think they should have had Luke win. In my opinion he could be ready for TV sooner than Andy. Luke also has the heel character locked up.